by Katherine Berdy, Faculty and Host of Leadership Podcasts, gcLi; Director, Youth Leadership Forum in Birmingham, AL
Let’s talk about what might be one of the scariest ideas of all: vulnerability.
For a lot of people, vulnerability feels risky, even dangerous. And for good reason—opening up about your experiences, especially around issues of race, gender, or identity, can leave you feeling exposed. It’s particularly tricky in conversations that cross demographic divides, where power dynamics, privilege, and histories of oppression may play a significant role.
But here’s the flip side: vulnerability is also the gateway to connection. When someone shares their honest, unpolished truth—about their fears, their hopes, their anger, their struggles—it creates a profound sense of intimacy. One can see humanity in a new way. What a gift!
Difficult conversations across demographic lines require a kind of reciprocal bravery: the bravery to be honest about who you are and the courage to truly see someone else for who they are. When that happens, something almost magical occurs. The divide that once seemed like an unscalable canyon suddenly feels smaller, and a little easier to climb.
Practical Tips for Facilitating Brave Conversations
By now, you’re probably thinking: Okay, this all sounds great in theory. But how do you actually “do” it? How do you create a space for difficult dialogue that strengthens relationships instead of tearing them apart?
Here are some facilitation practices to help you lead these conversations with care, inspired by the gcLi:
1. Set the Stage with Ground Rules or Norms
Begin by establishing ground rules that create safety for all participants. These might include:
– Confidentiality always. Participants can share the learning, but never the details.
– Everyone knows the objective of the conversation.
– Speak from the “I” perspective (e.g., “I feel” rather than “you should”).
– Honor the humanity in the room.
– Sometimes silence speaks volumes. Allow space for silence, and ask for clarification to clear up confusion.
2. Lead with Curiosity
Encourage participants to approach the conversation with a spirit of curiosity rather than judgment. This means asking open-ended questions like, “Can you tell me more about your perspective?” or “What has your experience been like?” Curiosity disarms defensiveness and paves the way for deeper understanding.
3.Model Vulnerability
As a facilitator, you set the tone. By sharing a personal story or admitting when you don’t have all the answers, you create permission for others to be vulnerable as well. Just remember: vulnerability doesn’t mean oversharing. It’s about being real and authentic, not raw.
4.Center Lived Experience
Encourage participants to share their stories and listen deeply to each other’s truths. Resist the urge to interrupt, debate, or “fix” someone’s feelings. Instead, create space for the stories to be fully heard and respected.
5. Acknowledge and Navigate Power Dynamics
Power dynamics around race, gender, and privilege can show up in subtle or obvious ways. Acknowledge them upfront, and actively work to create balance in the conversation. For example, be mindful of who’s speaking the most and encourage quieter voices to share their thoughts.
6. Emphasize “Repair, Not Perfection”
Mistakes will happen. Someone might say something clumsy or hurtful, and that’s okay. What matters is creating a culture of repair, where missteps are met with accountability and a commitment to learning—not shame or blame.
Final Thoughts: Brave Conversations Can Change the World
Difficult conversations aren’t easy—but they’re worth it. They’re a chance to connect with people on the other side of a demographic divide and say, “I care enough to try. I’m here to listen, to learn, and to grow with you.”
When we embrace discomfort, lean into vulnerability, and stay committed to trust-building, we turn tension into transformation. We create relationships that aren’t just polite—they’re real, honest, and deeply connected.
So, the next time you find yourself at the base of that steep hill, wondering if it’s worth the climb, I hope you lace up those boots and take the first step. The view from the top is incredible—and it’s one we can only reach together.
Link:
“Climb that Hill, Part 1: The Power of Difficult Conversations to Build Bridges Across Divides” by Katherine Berdy (gcLi Leadership Blog)
—
Katherine Berdy, M.Ed, is the executive director of Youth Leadership Forum (YLF), a time-tested leadership program for sophomores and juniors in the Birmingham, AL metro area. For 40 years, YLF’s mission is to foster meaningful relationships across Birmingham’s many demographic divides. Berdy is the former director of The C. Kyser Miree Ethical Leadership Center at The Altamont School in Birmingham, AL, where she created community partnerships and experiential educational opportunities for Altamont’s students. Katherine’s career and pedagogical foundations began in the mid 1990’s while working as an outdoor educator in the Rockies and Pacific Northwest. Since then, she has worked as a teacher, photographer, leadership and academic coach, mentor, and facilitator. Katherine has presented at SAIS (Southern Association of Independent Schools) and NNSP (National Network of Independent Schools) with gcLi. She holds a B.A. in Communication Studies from Vanderbilt University and a M.Ed. from the University of Montevallo. Her teaching portfolio includes classes in English, theater, creative writing, leadership studies, public speaking, and debate. In her spare time, Katherine enjoys traveling, hiking, reading, knitting, photography, and spending time with friends and her husband and two children.